What is The Best Training Collar For Your Dog in 2021? (Buying Guide)

How to determine the right collar for your dog?

To choose the ideal training collar, you need to define your needs. Indeed, if your pet weighs 50 kgs, some models will not be suitable, and the same if it is 5 or 6 kgs.

Other criteria are important and can influence the price significantly. The most glaring example is the reach. This is the maximum distance you can recall your dog. On the market, you can find spans of 200 meters as well as 1500 meters. However, unless you are using the product for a hunting dog or a large runner, you do not necessarily need such a distance.

In our buying guides for training collars from different brands such as Numaxes, Dogtra, or Petsafe, you will find more in-depth and argued tests. In case of doubt, they will allow you to discover more information. We try to follow with attention the evolutions of dog training and our guides do not forget the novelties.

Dog Training Collar: How To Choose The Right One? The Buying Guide

pack of PetSafe Remote Dog Training Collar

You are looking for an effective tool to educate your dog. A training collar would seem to be the ideal solution for your dog but you find yourself a little lost among the countless models on the market. There are devices with more or less long-range, more or less sophisticated or waterproof devices, heavy or less heavy, which work with batteries or with batteries, etc. Prices also vary from single to triple (or even more) and you naturally want quality without being fooled.

The first step in choosing the right training collar for your dog is to think about how you are going to use it. Depending on what you want to accomplish, you will indeed find devices more suited to your needs than others. Also, you will have to take into account your doggie (his size, his temperament, etc.) in order to be able to opt for a training collar that will perfectly meet his needs.

The scope of the necklace

All dog training collars are based on a device that has a transmitter (often a remote control, sometimes your phone) and a receiver (this is the electrode box attached to your doggie’s collar). The range of the device is the distance allowed between the transmitter and the receiver for the proper operation of the device. If the range is 700 meters for example, and you want to activate the collar via your remote control while your dog is 900 meters away from you, the collar will not work.

A short-range may in some cases suffice. This will be suitable for example for close training, in a house or a garden. A reduced range training collar will also allow you to teach your pooch some basic commands such as “sit” or “to foot” and also to control his unwanted barking.

A long-range (more than 700 meters) will allow a more diverse and extended use of your training collar. Such a device will be particularly suitable for energetic dogs who are not waiting for you and run off without warning. You can take your animal for a walk (know that it is not possible to attach a leash to a training collar) and stay calm if you live in the countryside with a runaway companion. It is indeed very easy with a long-range device to bring your dog back if he has decided to go on a mop alone or with other dogs.

Also, if you want to train a hunting dog, you will need a long-range training collar: dogs tend to stray a lot when tracking games, and it is always handy to be able to call them back or call them back. they are. Especially since the hunting grounds tend to reduce the range of training devices (because of obstacles: trees, vegetation, etc.). In addition, there will be added a bit later a little video that we found interesting on the subject of training:

 

Necklace with remote control or smartphone?

Most training collars work with a transmitter that is provided for purchase. This is a small remote control that will fit in your pocket most of the time. However,  some models of necklaces are sold without remote control for the simple reason that they can be controlled via your smartphone, thanks to the Bluetooth connection.
The advantage of such a system is that you will have less tendency to forget your transmitter when you go for a walk with your companion. It’s also convenient that you don’t have to carry a remote control. In addition, the downloadable smartphone applications are often clear and intuitive and allow easy control of the collar.

You will note, however, that such a system does not only have advantages. First,  for the collar to work well, You will need to have a good smartphone (or a good tablet) with a quality Bluetooth connection. Also, even with a high-end phone,  you usually won’t be able to get a great range with this type of training collar. So, it’s up to you!

 Waterproof training collar or not?

Another important element in choosing a dog training collar: the degree of waterproofness of the device.
The vast majority of cases are at least waterproof to runoff, that is to say, that if it rains, the device will hold up. You can also easily clean it with a slightly damp cloth. However, do not confuse runoff and submersion proof, it is very different! With a rainproof collar, your dog will not be able to take a dip. It is therefore not recommended to take it for a walk to the lake or to the beach.
In order for your dog to go in the water, you will need an immersion-proof training collar. Note that some have remote controls that are also waterproof (and even floating!): Rather nice for swimming with your doggie !.
Be careful, however: some immersion-tight training collars require regular maintenance in order to preserve their impermeability. For example, on certain models, you will need to change a seal from time to time.

 The functionality of the collar

Are you not too tech-savvy? You don’t like having to decipher a manual and take the time to understand how a device works? In short, you are only looking for a simple and practical tool for occasional use. So opt for a  minimalist training collar without too many features. There are some very reliable ones, with ranges which remain interesting, and which have the advantage of having an operation within everyone’s reach.
For example, the  Canicom 200 first has a very simple remote control with six buttons differentiated by icons/numbers and a color code. If it is not very sophisticated, this device has the merit of being very easy to use.

If, on the other hand, you are not afraid of technology and you feel like playing with the settings options, you would have a lot to gain by opting for a device that is a little more sophisticated. You could thereby educate your animal more professionally, with more nuances for a better result. You can find training collars which, in addition to having a good reach, offer interesting possibilities:

  • A variety of stimulation modes: you can choose your stimulation mode among 3 modes (sound, vibratory, electrostatic).

 

  • Several stimulation ranges  (low, medium, high) each comprising several levels of corrections for ultra-personalized use of the device.

 

  • An automatic anti-bark mode. This option enables the automatic release of the collar in the event of barking.
  • The possibility of training several dogs with the same remote control (will require the purchase of additional collars).

PetSafe SMART DOG Training Collar – Uses Smartphone as Handheld Remote Control – Tone, Vibration, 1-15 Levels of Static Stimulation – Bluetooth Wireless System – All in One Pet Training Solution

PetSafe SMART DOG Training Collar – Uses Smartphone as Handheld Remote Control – Tone, Vibration, 1-15 Levels of Static Stimulation – Bluetooth Wireless System – All in One Pet Training Solution

How to choose the right one Best Dog Training Collars Buying Guide

Check on Amazon

Battery or battery collar?

As with many small electrical devices, then there is the issue of powering the collar.  So you will find training collars running on batteries and others with a rechargeable battery.

As is often the case, although these devices are mostly more expensive, it is always more practical  (and more economical in the long run) to opt for a rechargeable collar.
If, however, you decide on a battery-powered collar, don’t forget to remove them from the transmitter and receiver. If you won’t be using them for a while, this saves them and also protects your devices.

The dog training market is not weakening and the available offer is enormous today. However, all models of collars for training your dog are not worth it, and given the rather high price, it would be a shame to be wrong.
This is why on this site, we give you our opinion on most of the training collars. To do this, we collect the opinions of enthusiasts and test extensively.

What is the price of a training collar?

The first prices start around $30. The majority of the dog training collars you will find at these prices are of poor quality. If you don’t believe us, take the test. For this price, an error of choice is not too serious. A small exception for the I-Clever brand which succeeds in offering necklaces at affordable prices and of acceptable quality.

The first very effective models are between $50 and $160, with brands like Numaxes or Petsafe. Their main functions work perfectly and your dog will react quickly to different stimulations. Do not hesitate to compare the various criteria mentioned in the previous chapter (the distance of the range, number of vibration levels, autonomy, etc.).



You also have high-end training collars like the Dogtra brand. Fearsome and with incredible precision, they allow very fast dog training. The vibration management is easy and you will quickly decide on the perfect level, so that your dog understands the recall, and that he does not suffer when you activate it. However, this exceptional quality comes at a price: from 170 to over $500. If you have the budget for or very frequent use on long, intense walks, treat yourself to this comfort. You will not be disappointed.

In passing, we specify that the price of the best dog training collars is not listed on the table because they often fluctuate on Amazon, and display errors could occur.

Leave a Reply